Pope Leo XIV Presses for Hostage Release in Meeting With Israeli President

In a significant moment of alignment between the Catholic Church and the State of Israel, Pope Leo XIV has placed the release of Israeli hostages by Hamas at the top of the Vatican’s diplomatic priorities, underscoring the moral urgency of their return before any lasting ceasefire in Gaza can be considered.

During a Thursday meeting at the Apostolic Palace, Israeli President Isaac Herzog met with the pontiff for what the Holy See described as a conversation rooted in humanitarian concern and international responsibility. The Vatican’s official statement left no ambiguity: “With willingness and courageous decisions, as well as with the support of the international community, the release of all hostages can be achieved.”

This is a rare and crucial point of agreement between Israel and the Vatican, especially in the context of the Gaza war. While the Vatican’s message included the predictable call for a ceasefire and humanitarian access, its clear prioritization of the hostages’ return mirrors Israel’s long-standing position: No peace can begin until the captives are free.

The Vatican’s statement, though also referencing the “two-state solution” as a long-term vision, stopped short of attributing that view directly to Pope Leo XIV perhaps a calculated move to maintain the Holy See’s traditional neutrality while recognizing the real, immediate evil of Hamas’s terror tactics.

This meeting comes as global pressure mounts for Israel to concede to ceasefire demands even while dozens of its citizens remain held in brutal captivity. The Vatican, by contrast, has now joined the small group of international actors acknowledging the moral and strategic necessity of hostage recovery as a prerequisite to peace.

Why This Matters

• More than 250 Israelis were taken hostage by Hamas during its barbaric assault on October 7, 2023. Many are still believed to be alive, held in unknown conditions in Gaza.

• The Vatican's recognition of hostage release as the top priority places pressure on other international players especially European powers and the UN—that have failed to condition ceasefire support on hostage freedom.

• Christian communities in the Middle East, many under threat from Islamic extremism, now have a clearer sign that the Church hasn’t abandoned them in favor of appeasement diplomacy.

Secretary of State Cardinal Pietro Parolin, a longtime figure in the Vatican’s foreign affairs apparatus, was also present during the talks. His past involvement in the controversial 2015 recognition of “Palestine” makes his participation all the more notable, signaling perhaps a shift in how seriously the Church now takes Islamist threats to peace, order, and basic human dignity.

President Herzog, speaking after the meeting, emphasized what many conservatives in the West have been saying for months: “All leaders of faith and goodwill must be united in calling for the immediate release of the hostages as a first and essential step toward a better future for the entire region.”

His remarks were not just polite diplomacy they were a clear signal that faith leaders have a moral responsibility to condemn evil, not rationalize it. And in Pope Leo XIV, Israel appears to have found a rare ally willing to stand on principle.

Too many Western institutions governments, universities, NGOs have been quick to demand “peace” without acknowledging the terrorists who shattered it in the first place. The Vatican's statement cuts through that noise. It recognizes that no peace exists when women, children, and innocent civilians are locked in tunnels by jihadists.

Let’s be honest: this should never have been a controversial position. And yet, in a world where moral clarity is in short supply, it took the Pope to remind the so-called international community of what should be obvious.

If nothing else, the meeting is a wake-up call for America’s own leaders. While the Biden administration wrings its hands over “de-escalation,” the Vatican is taking a stand for justice first, politics later.

Spread the word. Truth still matters especially when it comes from unexpected places. Share this article or subscribe to our newsletter for updates.