Illegal Border Crossings Expected to Decline Amid ‘Trump Effect’ 2.0

Donald Trump’s return to the White House is reigniting what many call “The Trump Effect” on illegal immigration. In 2016, Trump’s tough rhetoric and promises of border crackdowns caused illegal crossings to plummet, as migrants opted to stay put rather than risk deportation. Now, with Trump 2.0, history appears poised to repeat itself—but whether the impact lasts will depend on swift and decisive follow-through on Trump’s campaign promises.

During Trump’s first term, his hardline stance caused an immediate shift in migration patterns. Border apprehensions, which stood at 63,361 in November 2016, dropped to just 12,193 by March 2017 a historic low. Migrants south of the border admitted that the fear of deportation under Trump kept them from attempting illegal crossings.

Today, that same fear is taking hold once again. Pre-election interviews with migrants in Mexico revealed a near-universal anxiety about Trump’s return to power. A Ghanaian migrant in southern Mexico noted, “If [Kamala Harris] is elected, we know that everything is good, then we can enter.” Meanwhile, a Venezuelan migrant confessed, “We know that if Donald Trump wins, all the migrants will be kicked out of the United States.”

The Challenges Ahead

While the early signs of The Trump Effect 2.0 are promising, its sustainability is not guaranteed. As in his first term, Trump’s immigration agenda is expected to face fierce resistance:

• Legal Challenges: Liberal activist groups have already mobilized to battle Trump’s policies in court, with organizations like the International Refugee Assistance Project ready to obstruct deportation programs.

• Testing the System: Migrants are likely to conduct “test charges” at the border to gauge how strictly the administration enforces its policies. Success or failure in handling these initial waves will heavily influence migration trends.

• Lessons from the Past: By mid-2017, apprehension rates began creeping back up as litigation bogged down Trump’s key policies. This allowed mass crossings to resume, peaking in 2019.

However, Trump 2.0 enters the arena with important advantages. Many of the policies he plans to reinstate such as the Remain in Mexico program and asylum restrictions for migrants who bypass safe third countries have already withstood legal scrutiny. The courts have upheld these measures, giving Trump a stronger legal foundation this time around.

Public Opinion on Trump’s Immigration Policies

The overwhelming public support for Trump’s border policies also bodes well for their longevity. With more than 11 million apprehensions over the last four years of Biden’s administration, Americans have grown weary of unchecked migration. Polls consistently show broad approval for stricter border enforcement, and Trump’s re-election on an immigration shutdown platform sends a clear message: Americans are demanding action.

A Test of Will

The world is watching how Trump handles the inevitable surge of migrants testing his administration’s resolve. Migrants glued to encrypted apps will be paying close attention to the fate of those who challenge U.S. Border Patrol. The administration’s ability to swiftly implement deportations and deter future crossings will determine whether The Trump Effect 2.0 is a temporary phenomenon or a lasting legacy.

As Trump steps into his second term, border hawks are cautiously optimistic. With court-tested policies in place and overwhelming public support, the conditions are ripe for a crackdown on illegal immigration. But the key to success will be translating tough rhetoric into immediate, decisive action.

For updates on Trump’s immigration policies and their impact, subscribe to our newsletter today.