Tennessee Follows Florida, Authorizes Execution for Child Rapists

In a landmark move, Tennessee has become the second state to authorize the execution of child rapists. The new law, which went into effect on Monday, allows for the death penalty, life imprisonment without parole, or life imprisonment for the aggravated rape of a child. Tennessee GOP Gov. Bill Lee signed the bill into law in mid-May, mirroring similar legislation enacted by Florida Republican Governor Ron DeSantis in May 2023.

The U.S. Supreme Court's 2008 decision in Kennedy v. Louisiana deemed it unconstitutional to execute convicted offenders in child sexual battery cases. However, proponents of the new law hope the current conservative majority on the Supreme Court might reconsider and overturn this precedent. Tennessee GOP state Sen. Janice Bowling emphasized this, stating, “Maybe the atmosphere is different on the Supreme Court. We’re simply challenging a ruling.”

• The Kennedy decision, a 5-4 ruling written by Justice Anthony Kennedy, limited capital punishment to the "most serious crimes" with "extreme culpability."

• The case involved Patrick Kennedy, convicted of raping his eight-year-old stepdaughter, an act described in graphic detail by Justice Kennedy. The horrific nature of the crime highlighted the severe physical and psychological damage inflicted on the young victim.

• Supporters of Tennessee's new law argue that such heinous crimes warrant the most severe punishment available, underscoring a need for justice and deterrence.

Justice Kennedy's majority opinion detailed the brutal assault that led to Patrick Kennedy’s conviction. Police discovered the victim, L.H., in a severely injured state, and medical experts described her injuries as the worst they had seen from a sexual assault. This disturbing case has fueled ongoing debates about the appropriate penalties for such crimes.

As Tennessee's law takes effect, it reignites discussions on the death penalty and its application in cases of child rape. With Florida setting a precedent earlier this year, the push for capital punishment in these extreme cases reflects a broader conservative effort to challenge existing legal standards.

The outcome of these legislative changes could prompt significant legal battles, potentially reaching the Supreme Court once again. As the nation watches, the balance between justice for victims and constitutional limits on punishment remains a contentious issue.

Share this article or subscribe to our newsletter for more insights.