Outgoing NC Governor Commutes 15 Death Sentences to Life Imprisonment

On his final day in office, North Carolina Democrat Governor Roy Cooper commuted the death sentences of 15 men to life imprisonment without parole, echoing recent federal clemency actions by President Joe Biden. The move sparked debate over the death penalty's future in the state and added to a growing list of Democratic-led initiatives aimed at softening criminal justice measures.

“These reviews are among the most difficult decisions a Governor can make, and the death penalty is the most severe sentence that the state can impose,” Cooper stated. “After thorough review, reflection, and prayer, I concluded that the death sentence imposed on these 15 people should be commuted, while ensuring they will spend the rest of their lives in prison.”

Cooper’s Decision by the Numbers

• 15 Commutations Granted: This reduces North Carolina’s death row population from 136 to 121.

• 89 Petitions Considered: The Governor’s Clemency Office reviewed nearly 90 cases, ultimately granting clemency to 15.

• Racial Breakdown: According to NPR, 13 of the 15 individuals granted clemency are Black, reflecting ongoing concerns about racial bias in death penalty cases.

Cooper outlined several considerations in determining which cases merited clemency, including:

• The heinousness of the crime.

• Input from prosecutors and victims’ families.

• The defendant’s mental capacity, age at the time of the crime, and behavior in prison.

• Racial factors, such as the racial composition of the jury and evidence of bias.

• Adequacy of legal representation during the trial and appeals.

Cooper’s commutations follow a trend among Democrats questioning the fairness and morality of capital punishment. President Joe Biden recently commuted 37 federal death sentences, prompting critics to argue that such moves undermine justice for victims and their families.

North Carolina Republicans have pushed back on such decisions, pointing to the state’s 2024 election results, which showed a clear mandate for tougher law-and-order policies. Many conservatives argue that removing the death penalty weakens deterrence and sends the wrong message to violent offenders.

Josh Stein, Cooper’s successor, was sworn in as governor the day after the commutations were announced. Stein, also a Democrat, has not indicated whether he will continue Cooper’s approach to capital punishment.

As the nation grapples with these changes, the future of the death penalty in North Carolina remains a contentious issue.

Share this article or subscribe to our newsletter to join the conversation about criminal justice reform and public safety.