The Nancy Guthrie Case Exposes the Dark Side of Crypto Ransoms

The disturbing kidnapping of 84-year-old Nancy Guthrie, mother of NBC anchor Savannah Guthrie, has brought to light a growing and deeply troubling trend in modern crime: the use of cryptocurrency in ransom and extortion schemes.

Nine days after her abduction, kidnappers have demanded $6 million in Bitcoin by deadline, using anonymous messages sent to media outlets. As police scramble for leads, one thing is already clear Bitcoin has changed the game for criminals, and not in a good way for law enforcement.

Unlike traditional payment systems, Bitcoin offers what criminals crave most: privacy, irreversibility, and decentralization.

• No ID is required to create a crypto wallet just a digital key and a pseudonym.

• Transactions are final. There’s no bank, no chargeback, no customer service desk to undo a ransom payment.

• No central authority can freeze or block a wallet, no matter the crime involved.

According to Chainalysis, over $20 billion in cryptocurrency was linked to illicit activity in 2024, including human trafficking and physical coercion cases crimes that, more and more, are timed with Bitcoin price spikes to maximize payouts.

“Human trafficking operations have increasingly leveraged cryptocurrency,” Chainalysis reported, “with a disturbing rise in physical coercion attacks.”

But Bitcoin isn't entirely anonymous. Every transaction lives on an immutable public ledger, which offers a trail if you know how to read it.

Bezalel Eithan Raviv, CEO of crypto security firm Lionsgate Networks, explained how investigators can use small transactions to trace Bitcoin wallet activity.

“We would send a single dollar and trace the location of where it hits and lands,” Raviv said. “That intel can go straight to law enforcement without ever paying the ransom.”

Still, Raviv warned that the criminals are outpacing authorities in both technical skill and strategy.

“Cybercriminals understand the tactics,” he added. “Law enforcement will probably take years to catch up.”

The ransom for Nancy Guthrie originally stood at $4 million and was later raised to $6 million as the second deadline passed on Monday. As of Tuesday day ten of the ongoing search there has been no word from the kidnappers, and no sign of Guthrie.

Savannah Guthrie, in a heartfelt video posted to Instagram, pleaded with the public to pray for her mother’s safe return and urged anyone who noticed suspicious behavior to contact law enforcement immediately.

“We are at an hour of desperation,” she said. “And we need your help.”

While this case unfolds in real time, it also reflects a wider and rapidly escalating threat. Criminals no longer need access to banks or networks of middlemen they just need a QR code, a wallet, and a target. And with violent ransom attacks like this one scaling in both frequency and sophistication, cryptocurrency has become the preferred financial vehicle of 21st-century predators.

The blockchain may be transparent, but the people using it to inflict terror often remain in the shadows.

Share this article or subscribe to our newsletter to stay informed on the intersection of crime, technology, and national security.