Biden's Student Loan Forgiveness Halted by Federal Court

A federal appeals court on Thursday temporarily halted President Joe Biden’s nearly half-trillion-dollar plan to cancel or lower student debt by shifting the burden to taxpayers. The Eighth Circuit Court of Appeals paused Biden’s Saving on a Valuable Education (SAVE) Plan following a petition from a group of red states led by Missouri Attorney General Andrew Bailey.

The petitioners argued that the court should "enter an immediate administrative stay of Defendants’ actions to prevent millions of dollars in irreparable harm.” The group had previously succeeded in blocking a similar attempt by the administration to cancel nearly $500 billion in student loan debt.

Key Points:

• The SAVE Plan aimed to lower student loan payments by up to 50% and forgive any unpaid balance after a certain number of years.

• The plan faced legal challenges from multiple states, citing the financial burden on taxpayers.

• The Eighth Circuit's injunction indicates the court views the states' case as strong.

Missouri Attorney General Bailey criticized the plan, stating it would transfer debt from wealthy, elite college graduates to the working class, costing taxpayers $475 billion. The lawsuit reflects broader concerns about executive overreach and the circumvention of Congress’ authority over federal spending.

In addition to the Eighth Circuit's decision, a lower court in Kansas previously granted an injunction blocking parts of the plan, which the Biden administration appealed to the 10th Circuit Court of Appeals. That case has now been appealed to the Supreme Court.

Missouri’s case gained further traction when a Missouri court blocked a portion of Biden’s plan involving outright student loan forgiveness. The state’s appeal to the Eighth Circuit resulted in the current injunction, preventing the plan's implementation during ongoing litigation.

Additional Facts:

• The states challenging the plan include Missouri, Arkansas, Florida, North Dakota, and Ohio.

• In June 2023, the Supreme Court struck down another of Biden’s student loan forgiveness efforts, deeming it an overreach of executive power.

• The Department of Education has been sending emails to borrowers, giving Biden credit for attempting to forgive loans while blaming Republicans for the legal challenges.

Biden's administration has faced repeated legal hurdles in its attempts to push student debt forgiveness. The latest court ruling deals a significant blow to efforts to use the program to garner support ahead of the upcoming election.

As the legal battles continue, the fate of Biden’s student loan forgiveness initiatives remains uncertain, raising questions about the administration’s approach to executive authority and fiscal responsibility.

Share this article and subscribe to our newsletter for more updates.