InnovAge Holding Corporation, a Denver senior-care company, agreed to pay $36 million to settle allegations that it failed to provide required medical services and timely specialist referrals, the Justice Department announced Tuesday. InnovAge runs centers under PACE, the Program of All-Inclusive Care for the Elderly. CMS pays a PACE organization a fixed monthly amount for each enrolled Medicare beneficiary.

The government alleged that from May 2016 to October 2022, InnovAge failed to keep enough specialists in its network and, in thousands of instances, failed to schedule timely appointments for oncology, cardiology, surgery and neurology. Its own audits found significant delays, the department said, with many orders over a year outstanding. Senior InnovAge physicians complained to the company about the delays.

Two former employees brought the case as whistleblowers under the False Claims Act, filing suit in 2021 and 2022, The Denver Gazette reports. In 2021, CMS and Colorado's Department of Health Care Policy and Financing barred InnovAge from enrolling new Medicare and Medicaid patients in Colorado and California after audits found its facilities were not providing medically necessary care. The sanctions were lifted in stages between late 2022 and 2023.

InnovAge will pay approximately $25.7 million to the United States and a combined $10.3 million to Colorado, California, New Mexico and Virginia. The whistleblowers' share of the federal settlement will be $4.5 million. InnovAge denies the allegations, Edit USA reports.

InnovAge runs PACE centers in California, Colorado, New Mexico and Virginia, according to the Justice Department. The Denver Gazette reports the company provides residential and in-home care for seniors in Colorado and five other states. Under the program's rules, the department says, a PACE organization must provide comprehensive health care services, and every service must be delivered as quickly as the participant's health condition requires.

The department says InnovAge's internal reports of providers' medical orders regularly showed numerous and recurring delinquent specialist referrals. Several senior physicians told the company that its scheduling practices and delays harmed participants' health, put the company's own providers at legal risk and left InnovAge out of compliance with CMS requirements, according to the department. The Denver Gazette reports that, according to the settlement, the company kept submitting claims for Medicaid payments without disclosing that it was out of compliance with its regulatory and contractual obligations.

The two whistleblowers are former employees Monita Poudyal and Karen Lapcewich, the department said. Colorado will receive about $5.7 million after the federal and whistleblower shares are divided, The Denver Gazette reports. Colorado Attorney General Phil Weiser, who is also the state's governor-elect, said the settlement holds the company accountable. The Justice Department's Civil Division Fraud Section and the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Colorado handled the case with help from the HHS Office of Inspector General, and U.S. Attorney Peter McNeilly said his office is committed to holding PACE providers to timely and comprehensive care.

Why it matters

InnovAge calls itself the largest PACE provider in the country by participants served, The Denver Gazette reports.

Acting Assistant Attorney General Jonathan Guynn calls it a "first-of-its-kind" settlement over health care fraud by a PACE organization.